HARRY POTTER 5

[Weirdo/ Taki]

OOOOOOO Kati made a new thread!!!!!

So....
HPatOftP


What'd we think?

Luna was perfect.
No quidditch was bad.
Voldemort was creepy. And his head thing was weird.....
Harry was too much the focus; not enough of any other people except him.
I wish Snape's worst memory was longer; I wanted to get to really look at James, Sirius, Lupin, and Wormtail as kids. And Lily wasn't in that scene- also bad.
Umbridge was pretty good- she acted the part well, but didn't look like a toad. But the pink sweaters were perfect. And her attitude.

I'll stop critiqueing and leave some for the rest of you. Both of you.

[naturepenny]

Um...it was good agree with everything u said.

It was too focused on just the DA, there wasn't enough of just the school year.
It was too serious in a way.
Def not the best movie they have made but it wasn't the best book either.

Leah is here!!!!!!!!!!

[<~+*power*+~>]

i actually think they made a good attempt at capturing the main things in the book, and they actually tried to include some of the details.
BUT....
i totally agree about snape's worst memory, cause that's one of my favorite parts EVER.
i kind of thought Ron and Hermione should have been in it a little more.


i think the reason it was so focused on Harry is cause the book was....he had an inner conflict issue, and i guess it was probably important to show that. in the next movie it hopefully won't be like that.

and i loved luna! she rocked! and i also think they hinted at the whole Ron/Hermione thing. so yeah.

[Weirdo/ Taki]

I felt so bad for them though; Ron hardly ever smiled, he always looked all sad and like "Oh, why do you hate me???" But Fred and George were great!!! I loved the last fireworks, that was a big "W".

[naturepenny]

lol, fred and george rock!

[Weirdo/ Taki]

Yeah............. poor Fred and George................... although that's a different topic for discussion.

[naturepenny]

that's not in the movie

[Weirdo/ Taki]

I know, that's why it's a different topic for discussion.

So, who would buy it? I would..... I still have to get HP 4 on DVD.........